Land North of Browns Lane

Tamworth B79 8TA

APPEAL REFS: APP/K3415/W/24/3340089 (Appeal A) and APP/Z3445/W/24/3340094 (Appeal B)

Land north of Browns Lane, Tamworth B79 8TA

 

Outline application for up to 210 dwellings, public open space, landscaping, sustainable urban drainage, access, and associated infrastructure. (all matters reserved except access).

INQ – INQUIRY DOCUMENTS

Document ID Document Name Author
INQ A Case Managment Conference Agenda  Planning Inspectorate
INQ B Case Managment Conference Note Planning Inspectorate
INQ C Representations from Barwood Strategic Land Mrs Elizabeth Marjoram/Kings Chambers
INQ 1 Opening Statement of Hashi Mohamed of Counsel
INQ 2 Opening Statement of Piers Riley-Smith of Counsel
INQ 3 3rd Party Reps of David G Foster
INQ 4 3rd Party Reps of Daniel Griffiths (on behalf of Barwood)
INQ 5 Amended Table 4.1 of Appendix 1 to CD 7.1 (Appellant’s Planning Proof of Evidence) to show PM MMQ Mode
INQ 6 Lichfield District Ward Map and Affordable Housing Provision for Browns Lane & Arkall Farm
INQ 7 Tamworth BDL Maps
INQ 8 Closing Statement of Piers Riley-Smith of Counsel
INQ 9 Closing Statement of Hashi Mohamed of Counsel

CD01 – RELEVANT APPLICATION PLANS AND DOCUMENTS

1.1 – Bundle of Drawings

Document ID Document Name Author
1.1.1 Location Plan ProMap
1.1.2 Indicative Masterplan : P16-1451_05_2 rev K Pegasus
1.1.3 S278 General Arrangement Alternative Arrangement Extended : GGLE-HAD-OF-DR-CE-SK06 rev A Link Engineering
1.1.4 Site Access Arrangements : J32-4320-PS-001 Mode Transport Planning
1.1.5 Indicative Masterplan : P16-1451_05_2 rev L Pegasus
1.1.6 Sketch Layout : SKL 01 rev P2, dated 11.08.2023 Thrive Architects
1.1.7 Development Parameter Plan : DPP-01 rev P1 Thrive Architects
1.1.8 S278 Overview Layout : GG-LE-HAD-OF-DR-CE-100 rev D Link Engineering
1.1.9 S278 Overview General Arrangement : GG-LE-HAD-OF-DR-CE-101 rev D Link Engineering
1.1.10 S278 Vehicle Tracking Sheet 1 : GG-LE-HAD-OF-DR-CE-121 rev C Link Engineering
1.1.11 S278 Vehicle Tracking Sheet 2 : GG-LE-HAD-OF-DR-CE-122 Link Engineering

1.2 – Other Documents

Document ID Document Name Author
1.2.1 Design and Access Statement : P16_1451_12, dated July 2017 Pegasus Design
1.2.2 Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment : P16-1451, dated July 2017 Pegasus
1.2.3 Verified Views Report : V3D 171106, dated January 2018 vista3d
1.2.4 Built Heritage Assessment : JAC23011, dated January 2018 CgMs Consulting
1.2.5 Landscape & Visual Note : P16-1451 rev A, dated 3rd December 2019 Pegasus
1.2.6 Built Heritage Assessment (Amended) : JAC23011, Dated January 2019 RPS
1.2.7 BNG Metric (Excel) : Dated 6th April 2023 Cotswold Wildlife Surveys
1.2.8 Planning Statement : PF 9710, dated July 2017 Framptons
1.2.9 Planning Statement Addendum : October 2023 Summix Planning Limited

CD02 – LPA DECISION NOTICES AND COMMITTEE REPORTS

Document ID Document Name Author
2.1 LDC Decision Notice (18/00840/OUTMEI), dated 28th November 2023
2.2 TBC Decision Notice (0241/2018), dated 5th December 2023
2.3 LDC Committee Report, dated 6th February 2023
2.4 LDC Supplementary Committee Report, dated 6th February 2023
2.5 LDC Committee Report, dated 27th November 2023
2.6 LDC Supplementary Committee Report, dated 27th November 2023
2.7 TBC Committee Report, dated 5th December 2023

CD03 – RELEVANT PLANNING POLICY DOCUMENTS AND GUIDANCE

3.1 – Lichfield District Council

Document ID Document Name Author
3.1.1 Lichfield Local Plan Strategy : Adopted February 2015 LDC
3.1.2 Lichfield Local Plan Allocations Document : Adopted July 2019 LDC
3.1.3  Wigginton, Hopwas & Comberford Neighbourhood Plan Relevant Extracts (Policies WHC1, WHC3 and W1) : Adopted December 2016 Wigginton and Hopwas Parish Council
3.1.4 Biodiversity & Development SPD : Adopted 2016 LDC
3.1.5 Developer Contributions SPD : Adopted 2016 LDC
3.1.6 Sustainable Design SPD : Adopted December 2015 (Appendix A updated spring 2019) LDC
3.1.7 Emerging District Design Code SPD : Consultation Version Dated March 2024 LDC
3.1.8 Historic Environment SPD : Adopted December 2015 LDC
3.1.9 Wigginton Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Plan : Adopted December 2018 LDC

3.2 – Tamworth Borough Council

Document ID Document Name Author
3.2.1 Tamworth Borough Council Local Plan : Adopted February 2016 TBC
3.2.2 Design SPD : July 2019  TBC
3.2.3 Planning Obligations SPD : November 2018 (Revised)  TBC

3.3 – National

Document ID Document Name Author
3.3.1 National Planning Policy Framework : NPPF December 2023 Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
3.3.2 National Planning Practice Guidance (Relevant Extracts) : Various Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
3.3.3 National Design Guide : January 2021 Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
3.3.4 National Model Design Code Part 1: The Coding Process : June 2021 Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
3.3.5 National Model Design Code Part 2: Guidance Notes : June 2021 Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
3.3.6 PPG: Healthy and safe communities : Updated 7 August 2022 Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government

3.4 – County Documents

Document ID Document Name Author
3.4.1 Staffordshire Education Infrastructure Contributions Policy : March 2021 (Updated July 2023) Staffordshire County Council

CD04 – RELEVANT CONSULTEE RESPONSES RECEIVED

Document ID Document Name Author
4.1 Housing : 23.07.18 N/A
4.2 Housing : 11.04.22 N/A
4.3 Housing : 14.11.23 N/A
4.4 Tamworth Planning Policy & Delivery : 17.01.20 N/A
4.5 Local Highways Authority Form X (ii) : 13.01.22 N/A
4.6 Building Conservation and Design : 27.06.18 N/A
4.7 Building Conservation and Design : 30.12.19 N/A
4.8 Building Conservation and Design : 24.02.20 N/A
4.9 Building Conservation and Urban Design : 08.04.22 N/A
4.10 Building Conservation and Urban Design : 19.12.22 N/A

CD05 – STATEMENTS OF CASE AND STATEMENTS OF COMMON GROUND

Document ID Document Name Author
5.1 Appellant Statement of Case : 1049674.4 Statement of Case Marrons
5.2 Lichfield District Council Statement of Case Lichfield DC
5.3 Tamworth Borough Council Statement of Case Tamworth BC
5.4 Statement of Common Ground between Appellant and Lichfield Lichfield DC / Summix BLT Developments Ltd
5.5 Statement of Common Ground between Appellant and Tamworth Tamworth BC / Summix BLT Developments Ltd
5.6 Statement of Common Ground Addendum : May 2024 Lichfield DC / Tamworth BC / Summix BLT Developments Ltd
5.7 Statement of Common Ground Affordable Housing : May 2024 Lichfield DC / Tamworth BC / Summix BLT Developments Ltd

CD06 – OTHER RELEVANT DOCUMENTS (BY TOPIC)

6.1 – Planning

Document ID Document Name Author
6.1.1 Extract of Report on the Examination into the Lichfield District Local Plan: Strategy : PINS/K3415/429/5
6.1.2 Report on the Examination of the Lichfield District Local Plan Allocations 2008 – 2029 Proposed Submission : PINS/K3415/429/7
6.1.3 Committee Report on Local Plan Update : Dated 17th October 2023 Lichfield District Council
6.1.4 Economic Impact of Building Social Housing : February 2024 Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR)
6.1.5 LDC Five Year Housing Land Supply, 1 April 2023 to 31 March 2028 : July 2023 LDC
6.1.6 Local Development Scheme : March 2024 LDC

6.2 – Affordable Housing

Document ID Document Name Author
6.2.1 The Housing and Economic Development Need Assessment – Update : November 2020 GL Hearn
6.2.2 TBC Five Year Housing Land Supply, 2022 to 2027 : May 2023 TBC
6.2.3 Housing, Homelessness and Rough Sleeping Strategy : July 2020 LDC
6.2.4 Southern Staffordshire Districts Housing Needs Study and SHMA Update : 41022/MW/CRO/0, Dated 10th May 2012 Nathaniel Lichfield & Partners
6.2.5 Objection Statement to Appeal Proposals (Bellway Homes) :24123 Cerda Planning Ltd on behalf of Bellway Homes
6.2.6 Lichfield District 2050 Strategy : Dated 14th May 2024 LDC
6.2.7 Housing Strategy 2020 -2025 : December 2020 TBC
6.2.8 Homelessness Prevention and Rough Sleeping Strategy 2020-2025 TBC

6.3 – Heritage

Document ID Document Name Author
6.3.1 Conservation Principles, Policies and Guidance : April 2008 Historic England
6.3.2 GPA2: Managing Significance in Decision-Taking in the Historic Environment : July 2015 Historic England
6.3.3 GPA3.2: The Setting of Heritage Assets : December 2017 Historic England
6.3.4 Statements of Heritage Significance: Analysing Significance in Heritage Assets Historic England Advice Note 12 : October 2019 Historic England
6.3.5 GPA1: The Historic Environment in Local Plans: Historic Environment Good Practice Advice in Planning : July 20 Historic England
6.3.6 Historic Mapping N/A

6.4 – Design

Document ID Document Name Author
6.4.1 Design: Process and Tools PPG : Updated 1 October 2019 Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government

CD07 – PROOFS OF EVIDENCE

Document ID Document Name Author
7.1 Proof of Evidence of Ben Ward :Planning Marrons
7.1A Summary Proof of Evidence of Ben Ward : Planning Marrons
7.2 Proof of Evidence of James Stacey : Affordable Housing Tetlow King
7.2A Summary Proof of Evidence of James Stacey : Affordable Housing Tetlow King
7.3 Proof of Evidence of Gail Stoten : Heritage Pegasus
7.3A Summary Proof of Evidence of Gail Stoten : Heritage Pegasus
7.4 Proof of Evidence of James Atkin : Landscape Pegasus
7.4A Summary Proof of Evidence of James Atkin : Landscape Pegasus
7.5 Proof of Evidence of Mike Carr : Design Pegasus
7.5A Summary Proof of Evidence of Mike Carr : Design Pegasus
7.6 Proof of Evidence of Patrick Daly : Planning Lichfield District Council
7.7 Proof of Evidence of Gemma Hill : Affordable Housing Lichfield District Council
7.8 Proof of Evidence of Simon Roper-Pressdee :Heritage Lichfield District Council
7.8A Summary Proof of Evidence of Simon Roper-Pressdee : Heritage Lichfield District Council

CD08 – APPEAL DECISIONS AND CASE LAW (BY TOPIC)

8.1 – Planning

Document ID Document Name Author
8.1.1 Court of Appeal Decision relating to ‘Corbett’ : [2020] EWCA Civ 508
8.1.2 Appeal Decision relating to ‘Arkall Farm’ (Land North of Ashby Road, Tamworth, Staffordshire) : APP/K3415/V/17/3174379

8.2 – Affordable Housing

Document ID Document Name Author
8.2.1 Appeal Decision relating to Former North Worcestershire Golf Club Ltd, Hanging Lane, Birmingham : APP/P4605/W/18/3192918
8.2.2 Appeal Decision relating to Sondes Place Farm, Westcott Road, Dorking :APP/C3620/W/23/3324631
8.2.3 Appeal Decision relating to Land at the Corner of Oving Road and A27, Chichester : APP/L3815/W/16/3165228
8.2.4 Appeal Decision relating to Oxford Brookes University, Wheatley Campus, College Close, Wheatley, Oxford : APP/Q3115/W/19/3230827
8.2.5 Appeal Decision relating to Land to the west of Langton Road, Norton : APP/Y2736/W/15/3136237 & APP/Y2736/W/15/3136233
8.2.6 Appeal Decision relating to Land to the East of Highgate Hill and South of Copthall Avenue, Hawkhurst, Kent : APP/M2270/W/21/3282908
8.2.7 Appeal Decision relating to Land off Aviation Lane, Burton-upon-Trent : APP/B3410/W/20/3245077

8.3 – Heritage

Document ID Document Name Author
8.3.1 Court of Appeal Decision relating to ‘Barnwell Manor’ :[2014] EWCA Civ 137
8.3.2 High Court Decision relating to ‘Forge Fields’ : [2014] EWHC 1895 (Admin)
8.3.3 Court of Appeal Decision relating to ‘Mordue’ : [2015] EWCA Civ 1243
8.3.4 High Court Decision relating to ‘Nuon’ : [2013] EWHC 2847 (Admin)
8.3.5 Court of Appeal Decision relating to ‘Steer’ : [2018] EWCA Civ 1697
8.3.6 High Court Decision relating to ‘Safe Rottingdean Ltd’ : [2019] EWHC 2632 (Admin)
8.3.7 High Court Decision relating to ‘Kinsey’ : [2021] EWHC 1286 (Admin)

CD09 – SECTION 106

Document ID Document Name Author
9.1 Draft Section 106 Agreement LDC/SCC/Summix BLT Developments Limited
9.2 CIL Compliance Statement : Dated 21 June 2024 LDC